OK, quick, just who was the greatest horse ever to hear his hooves rattle over the dirt on a Saturday afternoon? Secretariat? Bold Ruler? Affirmed? Man O’ War? Forego? Maybe Citation, Spectacular Bid or Swaps? All true champions in their own right. But for my money, the greatest horse had to be Dr. Fager. Never heard of him? It must be because of some conspiracy that has relegated the guy to the dustbin of racing history. So, rather than listen to me, consider this from the legendary turf writer, Charles Hatton, writing about Dr. Fager in his “Profiles of Best Horses” column in the 1969 American Racing Manual, an influential publication that continues to issue year after year:
Dr. Fager was a singular performer as a four-year old in 1968. He was appropriatedly awarded Horse of the Year honors, which is the ultimate accolade, and excelled in more departments and divisional titles than any other horse since THE DAILY RACING FORM and The Morning Telegraph poll was instituted in 1936. William McKnight’s Tartan Stables homebred [Florida] also was proclaimed the handicap, turf and sprint champion all rolled into one.
Dr. Fager set and tied records from seven furlongs to a mile and a quarter, slashing the world mile mark to 1:32 1/5 en route. He did everything with flair, though he was not tested at cup routes and his stamina was not incorruptible by the iconoclasts. His prodigal wire to wire speed, his impartiality concerning track conditions, his bravery under fire and his ability to make light of enervating weights, elicited widespread acclaim.
In the course of the ‘68 season, Dr. Fager won the Roseben, Californian, Suburban, Whitney, Washington Park Handicap, United Nations and Vosburgh, and placed in the Brooklyn. He won from seven furlongs to a mile and a quarter, under weights ranging from 130 to 139, carried 134 pounds a mile in 1:32 1/5, winning the Washington Park Handicap by 10 astonishing lengths, and gave Advocator 22 pounds and a beating in his only start on grass in the United Nations. It required the combined efforts of Damascus and his surrogate, Hedevar, to negotiate his defeat in the Brooklyn, run in 1:59 1/5 for the 10 furlongs. At three, the Tartan flyer won seven or nine starts, including the mile and a quarter New Hampshire Sweepstakes at Rockingham in track record time of 1:59 4/5.
Conceivably, Dr. Fager was his own formidable foe. Except for being at once arrogant, conceited, impetuous and ingenuous, he might have never known defeat. A rank, headstrong individual who was a hard puller with a hard mouth, he always led trumps. Little Willie Shoemaker, with his delicate hands, never really fit him. Braulio Baeza got on fairly well with him, through cajolery and exercising care not to antagonize him.
Dr. Fager could never tolerate following a rival or stalking the pace once his blood was up, and his impatience had a low threshold. Rival riders knew this and in the Woodward, when he was three, they made a dead set at getting him on the muscle early in the race, yelling alongside him and slapping their whips to excite him into excessive use of his resources. Somewhat similarly, Hedevar had only to prompt him into the first turn to set him up for Damascus in the ‘68 Brooklyn.
[Trainer John] Nerud was delighted, naturally, to find the colt had phenomenal speed at two - and he made the most of it. Could he have foreseen what manner of horse Dr. Fager would become, the trainer might have endeavored to teach him to wait, rating behind horses in his work. But then this tactic often hs the effect of confusing and at length discouraging a horse so taht he does nothing well. Considering Dr. Fager’s nettlesome, volatile nature, it is quite possible he would have been utterly spoiled and too hostile for any use.
So, that’s my choice for the greatest thoroughbred of the 20th century at least and all on the accomplishments of that one year of racing - 1968. He won at any distance on any surface, carrying the unheard of weights of anywhere from 130 to 139. Trainers today scream bloody murder when racing secretaries assign 120 pounds in a handicap race. Dr. Fager would have taken the heads off the best runners if he were to go up against them today. Tell me that horses don’t have the will to win. Dr. Fager - #1.